AWeber vs Mailchimp Pricing by List Size for Small Business

Written by
AutoMarketer
Published
Reading time
8 min read

AWeber is cheaper than Mailchimp for most small business lists from about 2,500 subscribers up, and Mailchimp is cheaper only at the very bottom of the ladder. At 500 subscribers Mailchimp Essentials costs $13 a month against $15 for AWeber Lite. At 5,000 subscribers AWeber Lite costs $60 and Mailchimp Essentials $75, and the automation plans are $90 for AWeber Plus against $100 for Mailchimp Standard. The real gap is wider than the sticker, because Mailchimp counts unsubscribed contacts until you archive them.

Every figure below is monthly billing in USD, taken from the AWeber and Mailchimp pricing pages and our own tracked ladders for AWeber pricing and Mailchimp pricing. Confirm the final number at checkout for your exact list.

AWeber vs Mailchimp pricing at a glance

AWeber Mailchimp
Free plan A free signup is offered from the site header, check its current limits at signup 250 contacts, 500 emails a month, 250 a day
Entry paid plan Lite $15 a month at 500 subscribers Essentials $13 a month at 500 contacts
Automation plan Plus $30 a month at 500 subscribers Standard $20 a month at 500 contacts
Top self serve plan Plus, no higher public tier Premium from $350 a month at 10,000 contacts
What raises the bill Subscriber count Contact count, including unsubscribed until archived
Monthly send cap 10 times your tier on Lite, 12 times on Plus 10 times on Essentials, 12 times on Standard, 15 times on Premium
Seats 3 on Lite, unlimited on Plus 3 on Essentials, 5 on Standard, unlimited on Premium
Trial 14 days on Lite and Plus Free plan, promotional discounts on paid plans
Support 24/7 on every paid plan, priority on Plus Email and chat on paid plans, phone on Premium

Read the table by the plan you will actually use. Most small businesses that want a welcome sequence and a couple of tagged segments end up on AWeber Plus or Mailchimp Standard, so those two rows matter more than the entry prices.

AWeber vs Mailchimp cost by list size

Subscribers AWeber Lite Mailchimp Essentials AWeber Plus Mailchimp Standard
500 $15 $13 $30 $20
2,500 $35 $45 $55 $60
5,000 $60 $75 $90 $100
10,000 $100 about $110 $135 about $135

Two crossovers sit in that table. On the entry plans, Mailchimp is cheaper at 500 and AWeber is cheaper from 2,500 up, so the lines cross somewhere between those two tiers. On the automation plans, Mailchimp Standard is $10 cheaper at 500, AWeber Plus is cheaper at 2,500 and 5,000, and the two meet again around 10,000.

Annual billing changes the gap slightly. AWeber shows Lite at $12.49 a month and Plus at $19.99 a month at 500 subscribers when billed yearly, roughly two months free. Mailchimp discounts vary by promotion rather than a fixed yearly rate, so check the offer the day you buy.

Is AWeber cheaper than Mailchimp?

Yes, for most lists between about 2,500 and 10,000 subscribers. At 5,000 subscribers AWeber Lite costs $60 a month against $75 for Mailchimp Essentials, and Plus costs $90 against $100 for Standard. Mailchimp is cheaper at the 500 subscriber tier, by $2 on the entry plan and $10 on the automation plan.

Why the Mailchimp bill often runs higher than the ladder

The ladder above assumes your contact count equals your real audience. On Mailchimp it rarely does. Mailchimp bills on every contact in the account, subscribed, unsubscribed and non subscribed, until you archive them, as its help documentation on archiving contacts explains. It also bills on the peak contact total in the billing period, and the same person in two audiences counts twice.

A business that has run a Mailchimp account for four years with no cleanup often carries a large block of unsubscribed and bounced records nobody removed. At a real audience of 4,000 with 1,000 unsubscribed contacts still on file, Mailchimp prices the account at 5,000, so Essentials is $75 rather than the price for 4,000. AWeber prices on its subscriber count, so ask how your status mix is counted before you move. Before you compare quotes, export your Mailchimp audience and count only the subscribed rows. If the two numbers differ a lot, archive first and price second. Our guide to cleaning an email list walks through which records to remove.

What each plan gates

Price is half of the decision. The other half is which plan you are forced onto by the features you need.

AWeber Lite gives you one email list, three landing pages, three email automations, one custom segment and three users. AWeber branding stays on your emails and pages, and sales tracking carries a higher transaction fee. That is enough for one newsletter with a single welcome sequence. It stops working the moment you want a second lead magnet with its own follow up.

Try it while you read

See the marketing plan AutoMarketer would build for your business

https://

AWeber Plus removes those caps: unlimited lists, landing pages, automations, segments and users, advanced reporting, priority support and no AWeber branding. It is the realistic plan for a coach or creator with more than one offer.

Mailchimp Essentials covers campaigns, basic automations, three seats and templates, with a send cap of ten times your contact tier. Multi step journeys with branching, send time optimization and the more detailed reporting sit on Standard.

Mailchimp Standard is the comparable plan to AWeber Plus for anyone running sequences. It adds the customer journey builder, five seats and a 12 times send cap. Premium at $350 and up is built for teams with large lists that need unlimited seats and phone support.

So the fair head to head for a small business that wants automation is AWeber Plus against Mailchimp Standard, and at 2,500 and 5,000 subscribers AWeber Plus is the cheaper of the two by $5 and $10 a month.

Worked examples with real list sizes

A consultant with 450 subscribers and a monthly newsletter. About 450 emails a month and no sequences beyond a single welcome email. Mailchimp Essentials at the 500 tier is $13, AWeber Lite $15. The $24 a year gap is small, so choose on taste. Mailchimp has more integrations, AWeber answers support tickets at any hour.

A coach with 2,500 subscribers, a weekly newsletter and two lead magnets. Two lead magnets mean two follow up sequences, which rules out AWeber Lite (three automations, one list is tight) and pushes Mailchimp toward Standard for branching journeys. AWeber Plus is $55, Mailchimp Standard $60. Over a year AWeber saves $60, and more if the Mailchimp account carries unsubscribed contacts.

An online course creator with 5,000 subscribers and a launch twice a year. A launch week can mean six or seven sends to the whole list. At 5,000 subscribers AWeber Plus allows 60,000 sends a month and Mailchimp Standard the same multiple, so neither cap bites. AWeber Plus is $90, Mailchimp Standard $100, a $120 a year difference. If the course is sold through Shopify or WooCommerce with complex product data, Mailchimp's integration library may be worth the extra $10.

A local service business with 10,000 contacts collected over many years. Here the ladder ties on the automation plans at about $135. The deciding factor is the dead weight. If 3,000 of those 10,000 Mailchimp contacts are unsubscribed, archiving them drops Mailchimp to the 7,000 range, and the same cleanup makes the AWeber quote smaller too. Clean first, then compare.

Hidden costs on both sides

Mailchimp charges for overage blocks when you exceed your contact tier, bills transactional email separately, charges for SMS credits and charges for a custom domain on hosted landing pages. Each is documented, none appears in the headline price.

AWeber is simpler but not free of extras. Sales through AWeber pages carry a transaction fee, higher on Lite. The Done For You setup service is listed at $30 a month with a one time setup fee, shown as $79 when we checked, which is a one off build of a template, landing page and signup form rather than an ongoing writer.

Neither vendor charges you to write the email, because neither writes it. That is the cost most owners leave out of the comparison. If the newsletter takes two hours a week, that is about eight hours a month, the same block of time many owners already lose to admin jobs like keying supplier invoices into a spreadsheet, which is why tools such as invoicesocr.com exist for the bookkeeping side.

AWeber or Mailchimp, which should you choose?

Choose AWeber if your list is between 2,500 and 10,000 subscribers, you want support available around the clock, and your automation needs fit Plus. It is the cheaper sender through most of that range at the same list size.

Choose Mailchimp if your list is under about 1,000, you want the free plan while you start, or you depend on integrations with ecommerce, CRM and form tools that only Mailchimp supports. Budget for regular archiving, or the bill drifts upward.

If neither feels right, the next step down in price is MailerLite, which costs $49 a month at 5,000 subscribers on Comfort. Our AWeber alternative comparison sets AWeber, MailerLite, Mailchimp and Brevo side by side at 5,000 subscribers.

The part neither sender does

AWeber and Mailchimp both send what you wrote. Neither decides what next week's newsletter is about, drafts the welcome sequence or keeps the email in step with your blog and social posts. AutoMarketer does that part. Paste your website, and it builds a brand profile and drafts the emails, SEO pages and posts for your approval. Email copy is included from Growth at $149 a month, flat at any list size, and Starter at $49 covers SEO and social. You export the approved emails and send them from AWeber or Mailchimp, whichever wins your comparison. See every plan and allowance, or compare more senders in the Mailchimp alternative guide.

AutoMarketer

AutoMarketer.com